Answer · Published Nov 18, 2026
Information Blocking Rule for Providers, Explained
For practice managers and privacy officers: what the rule asks of a 1 to 10 provider practice, the setting to fix first, and a decision table for every delay.
The information blocking rule (45 CFR Part 171) bars a medical practice from knowingly and unreasonably interfering with access to, exchange of or use of electronic health information, unless a law requires it or one of ten exceptions applies. ASTP/ONC logged 809 complaints naming providers from January to July 2026. Check your portal's result-release settings first.
Key takeaways
- A provider blocks when it knows a practice is unreasonable and likely to interfere (45 CFR 171.103(b)(2)).
- Ten exceptions stand. The HTI-5 final rule of Oct 28, 2026 left Part 171 unchanged.
- A blanket hold on routine results does not qualify for Preventing Harm (ASTP/ONC FAQ, Sep 14, 2025).
- Claims naming a provider hit 809 in January to July 2026, against 184 in all of 2025 (ClinicOps count, ASTP/ONC data).
- HHS-OIG and ASTP/ONC said on Sep 4, 2025 that “enforcement is active” (HHS-OIG, 2025).
Want to know where your practice is weakest, from patient access to controls? The free self-serve score takes three minutes.
Score your practice in 3 minutesWho the rule covers, and the provider test
Your practice is covered. Health care providers are one of three actor types, with certified health IT developers and health information networks (45 CFR 171.102), and the rule has applied since Apr 5, 2021. A provider blocks when it “knows that such practice is unreasonable and is likely to interfere” (45 CFR 171.103(b)(2)). The data covered is electronic PHI in a designated record set, minus psychotherapy notes.
Complaints against providers jumped in 2026
ASTP/ONC counted 2,450 possible information blocking claims, its term for complaints, from Apr 5, 2021 to Jul 31, 2026 (ASTP/ONC, Jul 2026). A provider was the potential actor in 1,938 and a patient was the claimant in 1,554 (ClinicOps count from the monthly file).
| Year | Claims | Period |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 197 | Apr 5 to Dec 31 |
| 2022 | 246 | Full year |
| 2023 | 286 | Full year |
| 2024 | 216 | Full year |
| 2025 | 184 | Full year |
| 2026 | 809 | Jan 1 to Jul 31 (219 in March) |
The file does not say why. It does say who files: patients filed 725 of the 2026 claims through July. The people most likely to report your practice are your own patients.
The setting to check first: result release
Many EHRs hold results from the portal until a clinician signs. ASTP/ONC's answer to a blanket hold: “No. Blanket delays that affect a broad array of routine results do not qualify for the Preventing Harm Exception” (ASTP/ONC FAQ, Sep 14, 2025). A policy that delays lab results “for any period of time” for clinician review is likely interference, and so is EHI missing from the portal after login (ASTP/ONC FAQ, Sep 12, 2025).
HIPAA's 30 days to act on an access request, 15 days from July 17, 2027 (45 CFR 164.524(b)(2)) is not the target. How results get explained is your physicians' call: write it into your test results notification policy and set the EHR to match.
Can we delay or deny this request? The decision table
Every “yes” needs all of the exception's conditions, so the record matters as much as the answer.
| Situation | Allowed? | Basis | Record | Clock |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Portal holds every routine result until the physician signs | No | Blanket delays fail Preventing Harm (FAQ) | Setting change, date | Fix now |
| Physician judges one result could seriously harm this patient | Possibly | Preventing Harm: individualized, by a treating clinician, no broader than needed (171.201) | The determination | At the decision |
| Patient asked for a call before results post | Yes | Privacy: the patient's own request (171.202(e)) | The request | Reasonable time |
| A state law requires a delay | Yes, no longer than required | Required by law (171.103(a)) | The statute | Per the statute |
| Format you cannot produce | Offer alternatives | Manner, in the rule's order (171.301(b)) | Formats offered | No unnecessary delay |
| Cannot fulfill at all (outage, data you cannot separate) | Possibly | Infeasibility (171.204) | Written reason to requester | 10 business days |
| Fee for a patient's electronic access | No | Excluded from Fees (171.302(b)(2)) | Fee removed | Fix now |
| Planned EHR maintenance | Yes | Health IT Performance (171.205(a)) | Downtime window | No longer than needed |
| Cannot verify who is asking | Yes, per written policy | Security (171.203) | The check you ran | Per policy |
The first and seventh rows cost practices most: settings chosen once that nobody revisited.
Practice Controls installs written policies, an exception log and a review calendar in your own tools, then hands them to your team.
See what operations help costsWho enforces it, and what changed
HHS announced on Sep 3, 2025 that it “will take an active enforcement against health care entities” that block access (HHS via ASTP/ONC), and HHS-OIG and ASTP/ONC issued a joint alert the next day (HHS-OIG, Sep 4, 2025). For providers, OIG investigates and refers, and CMS applies disincentives through existing CMS programs the provider takes part in (89 FR 54662, effective Jul 31, 2024). HHS posts information about actors found to have blocked (45 CFR 171.1101). Penalties of up to $1 million per violation apply to developers, networks and exchanges.
The HTI-5 proposed rule (90 FR 60970, Dec 29, 2025) would have changed some exceptions, but the final rule of Oct 28, 2026 amended only certification rules. All ten exceptions stand.
What to do this week
- Practice manager: list every automatic result hold by result type, and remove blanket holds.
- Privacy officer: start an exception log (date, chart number, request, exception, conditions met).
- Practice manager: remove any fee for patients' electronic access.
- Owner: put the annual policy review on the compliance calendar.
Frequently asked questions
Does the information blocking rule apply to small physician practices?
Yes. Physicians and group practices are health care providers under 45 CFR 171.102, whatever their size, and a provider blocks when it knows a practice is unreasonable and likely to interfere with access to electronic health information.
How many information blocking exceptions are there?
Ten, as of Nov 2026: Preventing Harm, Privacy, Security, Infeasibility, Health IT Performance, Protecting Care Access, Manner, Fees, Licensing and TEFCA Manner. The HTI-5 final rule of Oct 28, 2026 did not change them.
Can we hold test results until the doctor reviews them?
Not as a blanket rule. ASTP/ONC says blanket delays on routine results do not qualify for the Preventing Harm Exception, but a clinician's individualized judgment about one result, or the patient's own documented request, can qualify.
What is the penalty for information blocking for a medical practice?
HHS-OIG investigates and refers its finding, CMS applies disincentives through existing CMS programs the practice takes part in, and HHS posts information about actors found to have blocked. The $1 million per violation penalties apply to health IT developers, networks and exchanges.
Is meeting the HIPAA 30-day deadline enough?
No. HIPAA allows up to 30 days to act on an access request (15 days from July 17, 2027, under the HHS final rule filed Nov 16, 2026), but ASTP/ONC reviews every delay case by case and calls a lab-result delay for any period of time likely interference.
Next steps
- The medical practice operations library
The system library this page belongs to.
- The medical records request process
The HIPAA right of access workflow.
- A compliance program for a physician practice
Where this policy fits.
- Medical office policy templates
File this policy with the rest.
- What operations help costs
When you want controls built and handed over.
Find your gaps before a patient does
Most information blocking problems are settings and habits nobody owns. Score your practice in three minutes, or book a free 20-minute call to walk through your patient-access setup.