Template · Published Nov 19, 2026
Medical Practice Internal Controls Checklist (Free Excel)
For the owner or practice manager who wants to know that no one person can take a payment, record it, deposit it and check it alone. You leave with the seven controls, a duties matrix and the 30-minute monthly review that catches what the controls miss.
The free Excel workbook: a duties matrix of 25 money tasks for up to 8 people, 16 incompatible duty pairs checked automatically, a compensating control for each pair you cannot split, 28 controls scored, the owner's monthly review, a red flags log, and a dashboard that sizes your open gaps with ACFE 2026 median losses.
Get the free internal controls checklist (Excel)A medical practice internal controls checklist makes sure no one person can take a patient's payment, record it, deposit it and reconcile the bank alone, and that the owner checks the money every month. Organizations with fewer than 100 employees had the highest median fraud loss in the ACFE's 2026 study, $126,000 (ACFE, 2026). Split those duties first.
Key takeaways
- In 2,402 fraud cases investigated from January 2024 to September 2025, organizations with fewer than 100 employees had the highest median loss of any size, $126,000, and health care organizations $100,000 (ACFE, 2026).
- One-third of those frauds happened because controls were missing, 19% because someone overrode them and 18% because nobody reviewed (ACFE, 2026, Figure 37).
- Where management review was in place the median loss was $84,000, against $186,000 without it, yet only 41% of organizations under 100 staff had it (ACFE, 2026).
- The federal internal control standard allows alternative controls when there are too few people to split duties (GAO Green Book, 2025, para. 10.23), which is the normal case at a front desk of two or three.
- A practice that takes more than $10,000 in cash from one person, in one payment or related payments, files IRS Form 8300 within 15 days (IRS, 2026).
The seven internal controls a medical practice needs
There is no official list of seven. GAO's Green Book, the federal internal control standard that state, local and nonprofit organizations may also adopt, lists 16 categories of control activities (GAO, May 15, 2025). For the money in a 1 to 10 provider practice, these seven cover what goes wrong:
| Control | What it looks like at the practice | Who | How often |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Separate the money duties | Nobody takes a payment, records it, deposits it and reconciles the bank alone | Owner assigns | Set once, checked monthly |
| 2. Approval limits | Refunds, voids, discounts, write-offs, new vendors and payroll changes over a set amount need a second person | Owner | Every time |
| 3. Restrict access | Own logins, void and refund rights by role, owner holds bank admin, access off the day someone leaves | Owner, manager | Quarterly review |
| 4. Document every transaction | A system receipt for every payment, a signed daily close, the void and refund log from the system | Front desk | Daily |
| 5. Reconcile | Each day's close matched to the bank by someone else; bank and card statements reconciled monthly | Manager or bookkeeper | Daily and monthly |
| 6. Count the cash | Surprise counts of drawers and petty cash by someone other than the custodian | Owner or manager | Monthly |
| 7. Owner review | The owner reads statements, logs and the payroll register, then signs | Owner | Monthly, 30 minutes |
The first control carries the others. In GAO's words, Management divides or segregates key duties and responsibilities among different people to reduce the risk of error, misuse, or fraud
(GAO Green Book, para. 10.04). The aim is that no one person controls every key step of the same transaction.
The internal controls checklist, line by line
These are the 28 checks in the workbook, four per control. Score each Yes, Partly or No, and be strict: Yes means it happened last month and there is proof. The workbook turns the answers into a score by control.
1. Separate the money duties
- Nobody takes a payment, records it, deposits it and reconciles the bank alone.The duties matrix finds every pair one person holds (GAO Green Book, 2025).
- Every pair you cannot split has a written compensating control the owner reviewed last month.
- Everyone who handles money took a full week off last year while someone else ran their duties.Job rotation or mandatory vacation: median loss $65,000 with it, $128,000 without (ACFE, 2026).
- The petty cash custodian does not approve the fund's replenishment.The petty cash policy has the full procedure.
2. Approval authority with limits
- Written dollar limits say who approves refunds, voids, discounts, write-offs, vendor bills and payroll changes.
- Refunds, voids, discounts and write-offs at or over the limit need a second person in the system.Refund rules are in the patient refund policy.
- The owner approves every new vendor and every change to a vendor's bank details, after calling a number already on file.Before you sign with a new vendor, run the vendor contract review checklist.
- Bank payments over a set amount need a second approver, or the owner releases every payment.
3. Restrict access
- Everyone has their own login to the practice management system, card processor and bank. No shared passwords.Unique user identification is a Required HIPAA specification (45 CFR 164.312(a)(2)(i)).
- Void, refund, discount and write-off rights are limited by role.
- The owner holds admin rights to the bank and processor; access ends the day someone leaves.45 CFR 164.308(a)(3)(ii)(C) calls for procedures to end access when employment ends.
- Safe and drawer codes are limited to named people and changed when one of them leaves.
4. Document every transaction
- Every payment gets a receipt printed from the system, and a sign asks patients to request one.
- The daily close sheet is signed by the closer and a second person.The end-of-day checklist is that sheet.
- The void, discount, write-off and refund log comes from the system, not a handwritten list.
- Cash over $10,000 from one person, in one payment or related payments, is reported on IRS Form 8300 within 15 days.Keep a copy 5 years (IRS, reviewed Jul 27, 2026).
5. Reconcile
- Someone who did not prepare the deposit matches each day's close to the bank's deposit record.
- Deposits go to the bank daily and intact, with nothing paid out of the receipts.
- Bank and card statements are reconciled monthly by someone who cannot sign checks or release payments.
- Card processor batches match bank settlements, and online and membership payments match the system.
6. Count the cash
- Drawers and petty cash are counted by surprise at least monthly by someone other than the custodian.Surprise audits: median loss $74,000 with them, $149,000 without (ACFE, 2026).
- Cash is locked away, and the change fund and petty cash are kept separate.
- Blank check stock is locked and check numbers are logged.
- Every count is signed by two people and filed with the month's records.
7. Independent owner review
- The owner receives bank and card statements and payment alerts directly and reads them first.
- The owner signs a monthly review of deposits, logs, new vendors and payroll.
- The owner checks the payroll register against the staff list every run.
- Staff, patients and vendors can raise a concern with the owner directly and confidentially.43% of frauds were found by a tip (ACFE, 2026).
The duties matrix: who may receive, record, deposit, approve and reconcile
A duties matrix puts every money task in a row and every person in a column, then checks which incompatible pairs sit with the same person. The workbook holds 25 tasks in five stages and checks 16 pairs. This slice is its worked example, a 3-physician practice with an office manager, two front desk staff and an outside bookkeeper.
| Money task | Owner MD | Office mgr | FD lead | FD 2 | Bookkeeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Take patient payments at the desk | Backup | Does | Does | ||
| Post payments in the system | Does | Does | Does | ||
| Open the mail and log checks | Does | Backup | |||
| Take the deposit to the bank | Does | Backup | |||
| Approve a patient refund | Backup | Does | |||
| Issue the refund | Does | ||||
| Add a vendor or change its bank details | Does | ||||
| Release bank payments | Does | ||||
| Reconcile bank and card statements | Does |
The office manager holds 19 of the 25 money tasks, which is common in a small office and is exactly where the conflicts sit. The pairs below are the ones to look for, with the median loss of the scheme each one allows.
| One person holds both | What it allows | ACFE median loss |
|---|---|---|
| Takes payments and gives discounts or write-offs | Skimming: the payment is never recorded | $45,000 |
| Opens the mail and posts payments | Skimming | $45,000 |
| Posts payments and carries the deposit | Cash larceny: taken after it is recorded | $45,000 |
| Carries the deposit and reconciles the bank | Cash larceny, hidden | $45,000 |
| Approves and issues refunds | False refunds and voids | $14,000 |
| Adds vendors and approves bills | Billing schemes: fake or inflated vendors | $90,000 |
| Releases payments and reconciles the bank | Check and payment tampering | $114,000 |
| Enters and approves payroll | Payroll schemes | $63,000 |
| Holds petty cash and approves its top-up | Cash on hand theft | $20,000 |
Medians per case from ACFE Occupational Fraud 2026, Figure 5. Backup counts too: the week the manager covers the deposit is the week a conflict gets used, so the workbook flags a pair whether someone does the task or covers it.
What a gap costs: the 2026 fraud numbers
The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners studied 2,402 occupational fraud cases investigated from January 2024 to September 2025. Organizations with fewer than 100 employees had the highest median loss of any size band, $126,000 across 459 cases, and health care organizations had a median loss of $100,000 across 137 cases. The typical fraud ran 12 months before anyone caught it, and 43% were found because someone reported a tip (ACFE, 2026). The cases are global and big enough for a fraud examiner to investigate, so they show what a gap costs when it is used, not how often it is used.
In the 140 health care cases, billing schemes showed up in 32%, expense reimbursement schemes in 14%, payroll in 11%, check and payment tampering in 10%, skimming in 8% and theft of cash on hand in 7% (ACFE, 2026, Figure 26). The cause was usually a control problem: lack of internal controls was the primary weakness in 33% of all cases, an override of existing controls in 19% and lack of management review in 18%.
The two cheapest controls on the list are also among the strongest in the data. Where management review was in place the median loss was $84,000, against $186,000 without it; with surprise audits, $74,000 against $149,000 (ACFE, 2026, Figure 28). These are associations in the case data, not a promise of savings. Medical groups say they act: in a 2018 MGMA Stat poll, 81% of 1,295 group leaders said they take steps against embezzlement, most often separating duties and running audits (MGMA Stat, Jul 19, 2018; older data from mostly larger groups).
The workbook checks 16 duty pairs against your own people, names the schemes your open conflicts allow and sizes them with the ACFE 2026 medians above.
Get the free Excel checklistWhen there are too few people to split the duties
Add a check after the fact. The Green Book expects this: if segregation of duties is not practical because of limited personnel, management designs alternative control activities (GAO, 2025, para. 10.23). In a practice, that means someone else checks the result, on a schedule, and signs.
| The pair you cannot split | The compensating control | Who checks, when |
|---|---|---|
| Front desk takes and posts payments | A system receipt for every payment, a sign asking patients to request one, and visits matched to payments at the close | Second person, daily |
| Manager opens the mail and posts checks | A second person logs checks as the mail is opened; the log is matched to postings | Second person, weekly |
| Manager posts and carries the deposit | A second person counts and signs the deposit slip; the bookkeeper matches the bank's deposit record to the close | Bookkeeper, daily |
| Manager approves and issues refunds | The owner approves refunds at or over a set amount and reads the refund report for repeat cards | Owner, monthly |
| A sole owner signs and reconciles | An outside bookkeeper reconciles anyway, so mistakes and bank errors are caught | Bookkeeper, monthly |
Two more cost nothing. A full week off for everyone who handles money, with someone else running the duties, was linked to a median loss of $65,000 against $128,000 without it, yet only 8% of organizations under 100 staff used job rotation or mandatory vacation (ACFE, 2026). And surprise counts by someone independent of the cash are the review Oregon requires for every state cash fund (Oregon Accounting Manual 10.20.00, effective Jan 27, 2026), a public-sector rule a practice can copy.
The owner's 30-minute monthly review
The owner's review is the control that catches what the others miss. Lack of management review was the primary weakness in 18% of the ACFE cases, and only 41% of organizations under 100 staff had it. Run these seven checks in the first week of each month, after the month-end close, and sign the row:
- Read the bank and card statements first, before anyone else has handled them. Look for payees you do not know and transfers you did not approve.
- Match deposits to the daily closes for a sample of days, including any day the usual person was out.
- Read the void, discount, write-off and refund log from the system. Look for one login, repeat cards and amounts just under the limit.
- Check new vendors and bank-detail changes against the approved list.
- Check the payroll register against the staff list: nobody paid who left, no hours nobody approved.
- Count one drawer and petty cash by surprise, and sign the count with the custodian.
- Review open conflicts and red flags, and give each one an owner and a date.
Red flags worth a second look
A red flag is a question to answer, not an accusation. These are the patterns the workbook's log is built for.
| What you see | What it can mean | First step |
|---|---|---|
| A deposit short of the close, more than once | Cash larceny | Someone else pulls the bank's deposit record and the close sheet |
| Voids or discounts on one login, each just under the limit | False voids or skimming | Compare them with the day's visits and receipts |
| Refunds to a card that did not make the payment | False refunds | Refund only to the original payment method; owner approves |
| A cash-paying patient seen but marked no-show or no charge | Skimming | Match the schedule, check-in times and payments for that day |
| A new vendor, or bank details changed by email | Billing scheme or payment rerouting | Call the vendor on a number already in your files |
| Someone never takes a week off or will not share duties | Behavioral red flag | Schedule a full week off with someone else running the duties |
Behavior matters but is not proof. In the ACFE cases, 84% of perpetrators showed at least one behavioral red flag; the most common was living beyond their means (39%), followed by financial difficulties (29%). Control issues or unwillingness to share duties showed up in 12% and refusal to take vacations in 5%, and 16% showed no red flag at all (ACFE, 2026, Figure 55).
Worked example: a 3-physician practice
Worked example
A 3-physician practice has a physician owner, a physician partner, an office manager, a front desk lead, a receptionist and an outside bookkeeper. The owner and the manager filled in the duties matrix in 20 minutes. It found 7 open conflicts, all involving the office manager, and a controls score of 55%. This is the workbook's sample, a worked example, not a client.
| Open conflict | Scheme it allows | ACFE median loss | The fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Takes payments and writes off balances | Skimming | $45,000 | Second approval at or over $100; owner reads the log |
| Opens the mail and posts payments | Skimming | $45,000 | Receptionist logs checks as the mail is opened |
| Posts payments and carries the deposit | Cash larceny | $45,000 | Second count on the slip; bookkeeper matches the bank |
| Prepares the deposit and matches it to the close | Cash larceny | $45,000 | Matching moves to the bookkeeper |
| Approves and issues refunds | False refunds | $14,000 | Refund approval moves to the owner |
| Adds vendors and approves bills | Billing | $90,000 | Vendor setup moves to the owner |
| Grants system access and posts payments | Override of controls | No figure | Admin rights move to the owner |
Before the fix, the schemes those conflicts allow had a combined ACFE median loss of $194,000 ($45,000 + $45,000 + $14,000 + $90,000, each scheme counted once), and each month one ran unseen would add about $15,200 at the ACFE's median pace per scheme ($3,800 + $3,800 + $1,200 + $6,400). ClinicOps calculation from ACFE 2026, Figures 5 and 9: a benchmark, not a forecast. Four reassignments and three written compensating controls took open conflicts from 7 to 0 and the manager from 19 money tasks to 15. Six pairs now depend on the owner's monthly review, which is why that review is on the calendar.
Mistakes to avoid
- Splitting duties on paper only. If the manager covers the deposit every vacation, the split is gone for two weeks a year. Count backups.
- Letting people review their own work. Whoever voids does not review the void log; whoever deposits does not reconcile the bank.
- Signing without reading. An owner who signs every check but never reads the statement has a signature, not a review.
- Leaving void and refund rights open to everyone. Limit them by role in the system, then read the log.
- Confronting someone before securing the records. Call your CPA and an attorney first; evidence is easy to lose once someone knows.
- Download the workbook and fill in the duties matrix with your own people (about 20 minutes).
- Fix the most expensive open conflict first: move the duty if you can, write the compensating control if you cannot.
- Have bank and card statements and payment alerts go to the owner directly.
- Book the owner's first 30-minute review for the first week of next month.
- Put a full week off on the calendar for whoever runs the deposits, with someone else running them.
By the numbers
| Figure | What it measures | Source and year |
|---|---|---|
| 2,402 cases | Occupational fraud cases investigated Jan 2024 to Sep 2025, global | ACFE, 2026 |
| $126,000; $100,000 | Median loss, organizations under 100 employees; health care organizations | ACFE, 2026 |
| 12 months; 43% | Median time a fraud ran; share found by a tip | ACFE, 2026 |
| 33%; 19%; 18% | Primary weakness: missing controls; override; no management review | ACFE, 2026 |
| $84,000 vs $186,000 | Median loss with and without management review | ACFE, 2026 |
| $74,000 vs $149,000 | Median loss with and without surprise audits | ACFE, 2026 |
| $65,000 vs $128,000 | Median loss with and without job rotation or mandatory vacation | ACFE, 2026 |
| 41%, 16%, 8%, 24% | Organizations under 100 staff with management review, surprise audits, mandatory vacation, a hotline | ACFE, 2026 |
| $114,000 to $14,000 | Median loss per case by scheme, tampering to false voids and refunds | ACFE, 2026 |
| 84%; 39%; 12%; 5% | Perpetrators with any behavioral red flag; living beyond means; control issues; refusing vacations | ACFE, 2026 |
| 16 categories | Common categories of control activities, including segregation of duties | GAO Green Book, 2025 |
| $10,000; 15 days; 5 years | Form 8300 cash threshold, filing deadline, copy kept | IRS, 2026 |
| 81% of 1,295 | Medical group leaders taking steps against embezzlement (older data) | MGMA Stat, 2018 |
| $194,000; $15,200 | Worked example: median loss of the schemes left open; added per month unseen | ClinicOps calculation from ACFE, 2026 |
- The medical practice operations library
Every system for a 1 to 10 physician practice.
- SOPs, controls and compliance
The pillar this checklist belongs to.
- Month-end close checklist
Every deposit explained and one signed page of numbers, the companion to this review.
- Medical office petty cash policy
The policy, voucher and monthly count for the smallest cash fund in the office.
- Policies and procedures manual
Where the written cash policies live; its free binder template has a cash chapter.
- What an operations consultant costs
When you want the controls designed and installed for you.
Find out who holds too much of your money trail
The workbook shows the gaps and what they have cost elsewhere. If you want the duties reassigned, the compensating controls written into your procedures and the owner's review set up inside the tools you already use, start with the free Chaos Audit; our Practice Controls install builds the cash controls with the SOPs that carry them.
Frequently asked questions
What are the 7 internal control procedures?
There is no single official list. The version most often repeated is separation of duties, access controls, physical audits, standardized documentation, trial balances, periodic reconciliations and approval authority. For a medical practice's money, the seven that matter are separating duties, approval limits, restricted access, documentation, reconciliation, surprise cash counts and the owner's monthly review.
What are the 5 components of internal control?
Control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring. They come from the COSO framework and GAO's Green Book, which nonfederal organizations may also adopt. A practice's checklist lives mostly in control activities and monitoring.
Should the office manager sign checks?
Not if the office manager also approves bills, adds vendors or reconciles the bank. Keep payment release with the owner or a second approver in the bank, and give reconciliation to someone who cannot pay. Check and payment tampering had the highest median loss of the cash schemes in the ACFE's 2026 study, $114,000.
How often should a medical practice review its internal controls?
Match each day's close to the bank deposit every business day, have the owner sign a 30-minute review every month, review system and bank access every quarter, and re-score the full checklist every January. Update the duties matrix whenever someone joins, leaves or takes over a money task.
What should I do if I suspect an employee is stealing?
Do not confront them alone or tip them off. Secure the bank, card processor and system reports, quietly limit the person's access to money, write down what you saw and when, and call your CPA and an attorney before you act. A red flag is a question to answer, not proof.
How do you separate duties in a small medical office?
Split the money trail so the person who takes a payment does not deposit it, and the person who deposits does not reconcile the bank. Where there are too few people to split every pair, add a compensating control: someone else checks the result after the fact, and the owner reviews it every month.